top of page
Clean Reads wth the Girlzzz logo

PREVIOUS POST

book cover of Eloise and the Grump Next Door by Emma St. Clair and Jenny Proctor

Oakley Island #1

ELOISE AND THE GRUMP NEXT DOOR
EMMA ST. CLAIR, JENNY PROCTOR
3.5/5 star rating

3.5 Stars

L

V

S

THIS POST

NEXT POST

book cover of Eloise and the Grump Next Door by Emma St. Clair and Jenny Proctor
Heading 6
Heading 6
Heading 6
Heading 6
Heading 6
Heading 6
Heading 6
Heading 6
Heading 6
Heading 6
Buy Eloise and the Grump Next Door on Amazon

As Amazon Associates,

we earn from qualifying purchases.

Oakley Island #1

ELOISE AND THE GRUMP NEXT DOOR

EMMA ST. CLAIR, JENNY PROCTOR
3.5/5 star rating

3.5 Stars

Eloise had hoped to spend the next year in grad school studying literature, but life took an unexpected turn. Her grandmother passed away and left her estate to Eloise and her two sisters. They are required to renovate the estate into a Bed and Breakfast while at least one of them lives on the island and oversees the project. As the sister with no job and no plans, Eloise is the one to stay and work with Jake, Gran’s lawyer and neighbor.


Emma St. Clair and Jenny Proctor are a couple of my favorite authors at the moment so I was very interested in reading this book that they’ve written together. I read that they wrote every other chapter and agreed that they could change what the other wrote if they weren’t loving it, so when they were going back through it, they couldn’t tell for sure who had written which parts. Impressive! I’ve never been great at group projects so I can’t even imagine that!


Eloise and the Grump Next Door was a cute romance read. You know I love these types of stories. The characters were fun–I especially loved all the Oakley Island residents and their interest in each other’s lives. The barber has a TikTok account where he posts all the juicy gossip. The community was really sweet. It made me want to live there. I thought Jake was a confusing character though. He was 11 years older than Eloise, so between their age difference and the fact that he was her grandmother’s lawyer, he felt the need to keep things professional between them regardless of his attraction to her. That made sense. But then he flipped that switch so fast I got whiplash! I don’t recall any reasoning for his change of heart. One minute he can’t get away from her fast enough, the next he’s cuddling her on the couch while watching a movie with his nephew. If I was Eloise, I’d need more of an explanation before any cuddling could happen. Though this is a ‘no spice’ romance, there is plenty of ogling going on and moments of nudity that weren’t necessarily spicy but it felt like a little higher on the scale of ‘no spice’ so just be aware of that. I do think they set us up for the next book pretty well though. I do think I’ll keep reading the series.

Content Warnings (may contain spoilers)
clean read stamp
signed the girlzzz

CONTENT RATING

LANGUAGE

1 on a scale of 1 to 5

None.

VIOLENCE/GORE

1 on a scale of 1 to 5

None.

SPICE

3 on a scale of 1 to 5

There is a male/female relationship to the extent of kissing. There are moments of brief nudity (in a towel after a shower, swim suit lost in the ocean) and they are ogled/admired.

GarberStephanie-Caraval-min.png

Caraval #1

ONCE UPON A BROKEN HEART
STEPHANIE GARBER
StarRating-5.png

5 Stars

L

V

S

GarberStephanie-Caraval-min.png

Caraval #1

ONCE UPON A BROKEN HEART
STEPHANIE GARBER
StarRating-5.png

5 Stars

L

V

S

GarberStephanie-Caraval-min.png

Caraval #1

ONCE UPON A BROKEN HEART
STEPHANIE GARBER
StarRating-5.png

5 Stars

L

V

S

see more in series

OAKLEY ISLAND SERIES

ALSO BY EMMA ST. CLAIR, JENNY PROCTOR

GarberStephanie-Caraval-min.png

Caraval #1

ONCE UPON A BROKEN HEART
STEPHANIE GARBER
StarRating-5.png

5 Stars

L

V

S

GarberStephanie-Caraval-min.png

Caraval #1

ONCE UPON A BROKEN HEART
STEPHANIE GARBER
StarRating-5.png

5 Stars

L

V

S

GarberStephanie-Caraval-min.png

Caraval #1

ONCE UPON A BROKEN HEART
STEPHANIE GARBER
StarRating-5.png

5 Stars

L

V

S

see more by author

bottom of page